Self-Publishing vs Traditional Publishing by Kathy Shanks

Self-publishing versus traditional publishing is one of the commonly asked questions by up-and-coming authors. Each path offers its own advantages, drawbacks, and considerations. The key is to understand what those are before deciding which path to take. Additionally, there’s a term that often surfaces in conversations about publishing, which is ‘vanity press.’ In this article, we will explore the differences between self-publishing and traditional publishing, and shed light on what a vanity press is.

Self-Publishing: Empowerment and Control

Self-publishing has gained immense popularity over the last decade, thanks in large part to the digital revolution. Authors who opt for self-publishing retain complete control over their work. Here are some key aspects to consider:

Ownership and Control: Self-published authors have full ownership of their work, from the content to the cover design. They make all decisions about the book’s appearance, pricing, and marketing strategies.

Speed to Market: Self-publishing offers a faster route to getting your book in the hands of readers. You can set your own timeline for publication.

Royalties: Authors typically earn higher royalties per sale in self-publishing, often ranging from 35% to 70% of the book’s price, depending on the platform.

Creative Freedom: Self-publishing allows authors to experiment with various genres, formats, and writing styles without the constraints of market trends or publisher preferences.

Marketing Responsibility: However, self-published authors are responsible for marketing their books, which can be challenging and time-consuming.

Self-publishing should not be misunderstood as a purely DIY endeavour. There exists a misconception within the industry that “paying anyone to assist in your publishing journey is a scam.” However, the reality is more akin to dining out at a restaurant. Sure, you could procure all the ingredients and attempt to prepare a meal from scratch, but do you genuinely desire to master the intricate art of flambé or the delicate craft of confit? Or would you prefer to entrust your culinary experience to a seasoned chef?

Similarly, if you were to self-publish, you have the option to acquire expertise from professionals. While it is possible to learn and execute each facet of publishing independently, there is immense value in engaging the services of those who possess years of experience and knowledge. For instance, it’s advisable to enlist the assistance of external editors to meticulously review your work. A professional designer can skillfully bring the layout and design of your book together, elevating its overall presentation.

You could plod-along attempting to learn every single step of the journey, or engage the services of someone who can guide you along the way. In essence, the question arises: do you merely want to “get a book out there” or do you aspire to craft a book that not only exists but also resonates with readers and sells successfully?

Seeking external assistance ensures the creation of a professional and polished product, all while you retain control over the creative process. It’s a harmonious blend of expertise and authorial control, allowing you to reap the full benefits of royalty payments while delivering a book that stands out in the market.

Traditional Publishing: Validation and Support

Traditional publishing, on the other hand, involves the collaboration between an author and a publishing house. Here’s what you need to know:

Validation: Traditional publishing is often perceived as a stamp of approval. Being accepted by a reputable publisher can boost an author’s credibility.

Editorial and Marketing Support: Publishers provide professional editing, cover design, and marketing support. They also handle distribution to bookstores.

Advance and Royalties: Authors typically receive an advance against royalties, but the royalty rates are lower, typically ranging from 5% to 15% of the book’s price.

Longer Timelines: Traditional publishing can take a year or more from manuscript submission to book release due to the lengthy editorial and production processes.

Limited Creative Control: Authors may have less control over cover design, title, and even content edits, as publishers aim to align the book with their target market.

Understanding Vanity Press: A Cautionary Note

Now, let’s demystify the term “vanity press.” Vanity presses are often criticised in the publishing industry because they exploit authors’ dreams of seeing their work in print. Here’s what you need to know:

Payment by Authors: In a vanity press arrangement, authors pay the press to publish their book, often at a high cost. This is in stark contrast to traditional publishing, where publishers pay authors for the rights to their work.

Limited Quality Control: Vanity presses may not uphold the same editorial and design standards as traditional publishers. This can result in poorly edited and unprofessional-looking books.

Minimal Distribution and Marketing: Vanity presses typically provide limited distribution and marketing support, leaving authors responsible for promoting and selling their books.

Questionable Reputation: Many vanity presses prioritise profit over the quality of the books they produce. Authors who choose this route risk being associated with subpar publishing practices.

In essence, vanity presses profit from authors’ dreams and aspirations without offering the quality and support that both self-publishing and traditional publishing can provide. A publisher should NEVER charge you an upfront publishing cost AND take a percentage of your royalties. Authors should exercise caution and thoroughly research any publisher they consider, ensuring they are not dealing with a vanity press.

Choosing the Right Path for You

When deciding between self-publishing and traditional publishing, authors must consider their goals, resources, and preferences. Some authors thrive in self-publishing, relishing the creative control and higher royalties, while others prefer the validation and support of traditional publishing.

It’s essential to weigh the pros and cons carefully and make an informed decision. If you do choose to pursue traditional publishing, research reputable literary agents and publishing houses that align with your genre and style. If self-publishing is your path, invest in professional editing, cover design, and marketing to ensure your book reaches its full potential.

In conclusion, the choice between self-publishing and traditional publishing is a deeply personal one that depends on your individual goals and circumstances. While both paths have their merits, it’s crucial to avoid vanity presses and prioritise the quality and professionalism of your work. With the right approach and dedication, your dream of becoming a published author can become a reality, regardless of the publishing route you choose.

The Turtle Publishing Difference

At Turtle Publishing, we are dedicated to guiding you through every step of the self-publishing journey. You have the flexibility to choose how you’d like us to assist you. Whether you’re seeking a professional book cover design or prefer to entrust us with your complete manuscript for comprehensive services encompassing editing, formatting, cover design, uploads, keyword optimisation, online distribution, and Amazon Advertising, we’re here to cater to your specific needs.

Our approach is tailored to meet you where you currently stand, taking into account your existing knowledge and expertise. We seamlessly integrate your unique insights with our wealth of experience to ensure you receive the best value for your investment in your book publishing journey.

By collaborating with us, you not only save valuable time, leveraging our expertise, but also make financially prudent decisions throughout the process. Self-publishing can be a steep learning curve for many, and whether you desire to learn the intricacies of the process with our guidance or prefer to have us handle it all for you, our dedicated team is here to provide the support you need.

Book a 20-minute free consultation with us, and let’s see how we can help your book dream come true,

Kathy Shanks

Kathy Shanks is the pioneer of Turtle Publishing and assists writers with editing, design, illustration, self publishing, optimisation for selling on Amazon, interior formatting and overall book writing support! An amazing service all under the one roof.

Add comment


Join our e-newsletter and hear about our latest news and insights.


Click on the Cover to Read About Dr Judith Orloff

Welcome Barbara Brewster!

Dom LivKamal’s Medicine Room

Download our FREE Holistic Bliss App!

Pitch, Write and Be Seen by Vanessa Finnigan!

Vanessa Finnigan, founder, being interviewed in Europe

Follow us

Don't be shy, get in touch. We love meeting interesting people and making new friends.

Most popular

Most discussed